CVE-2020-10932 An issue was discovered in Arm Mbed TLS before 2.16.6 and 2.7.x before 2.7.15. An attacker that can get precise enough side-channel measurements can recover the long-term ECDSA private key by (1) reco...
- Published
- Updated
- Exploit status
- No public exploit known
- Technology
- UbuntuDebian
Description
An issue was discovered in Arm Mbed TLS before 2.16.6 and 2.7.x before 2.7.15. An attacker that can get precise enough side-channel measurements can recover the long-term ECDSA private key by (1) reconstructing the projective coordinate of the result of scalar multiplication by exploiting side channels in the conversion to affine coordinates; (2) using an attack described by Naccache, Smart, and Stern in 2003 to recover a few bits of the ephemeral scalar from those projective coordinates via several measurements; and (3) using a lattice attack to get from there to the long-term ECDSA private key used for the signatures. Typically an attacker would have sufficient access when attacking an SGX enclave and controlling the untrusted OS.
Upgrade path
31 packages: 26 fixed, 3 with no fix yet.
| Package | Affected | Fixed in | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu 16.04) | = 2.1.2-1; = 2.2.0-1; = 2.2.1-1; = 2.2.1-2 +4 more | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu Pro 18.04) | = 2.5.1-1ubuntu1; = 2.6.0-1; = 2.7.0-2; = 2.8.0-1 +2 more | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu Pro 20.04) | = 2.16.2-1; = 2.16.3-1; = 2.16.4-1ubuntu2; = 2.16.4-1ubuntu2+esm1 +1 more | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.10) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.11) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.12) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.13) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.14) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.15) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.16) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.17) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.18) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.19) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.20) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.21) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.22) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.23) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine v3.24) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls2(Alpine v3.20) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls2(Alpine v3.21) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls2(Alpine v3.22) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls2(Alpine v3.23) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls2(Alpine v3.24) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/mbedtls3(Alpine v3.24) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 | Fixed |
| Arm Ltd mbed tls | >= 2.7.0, < 2.7.15 | 2.7.15 | Fixed |
| debian/mbedtls(Debian 12) | < 2.16.9-0.1 | 2.16.9-0.1 | Fixed |
| debian/mbedtls(Debian 13) | < 2.16.9-0.1 | 2.16.9-0.1 | Fixed |
| debian/mbedtls(Debian 14) | < 2.16.9-0.1 | 2.16.9-0.1 | Fixed |
| TrustedFirmware Mbed TLS | >= 2.16.0, < 2.16.6 | 2.16.6 | Fixed |
| debian linux | = 10.0 | No fix listed | Versions listed |
… and 1 more package.
Affected products
| Product | Affected versions | Fixed in |
|---|---|---|
| debian/mbedtls(Debian:12) | < 2.16.9-0.1 | 2.16.9-0.1 |
| debian/mbedtls(Debian:13) | < 2.16.9-0.1 | 2.16.9-0.1 |
| debian/mbedtls(Debian:14) | < 2.16.9-0.1 | 2.16.9-0.1 |
| Arm Ltd mbed tls | >= 2.7.0, < 2.7.15 | 2.7.15 |
| TrustedFirmware Mbed TLS | >= 2.16.0, < 2.16.6 | 2.16.6 |
| fedoraproject fedora | = 31 | No fix listed |
| fedoraproject fedora | = 32 | No fix listed |
| debian linux | = 10.0 | No fix listed |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.10) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.11) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.12) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.13) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.14) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.15) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.16) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.17) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.18) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.19) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.20) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.21) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.22) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.23) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls(Alpine:v3.24) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls2(Alpine:v3.20) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls2(Alpine:v3.21) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
Show 23 more
| Product | Affected versions | Fixed in |
|---|---|---|
| alpine/mbedtls2(Alpine:v3.22) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls2(Alpine:v3.23) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls2(Alpine:v3.24) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| alpine/mbedtls3(Alpine:v3.24) | < 2.16.6-r0 | 2.16.6-r0 |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:16.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 2.1.2-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 2.2.0-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 2.2.1-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 2.2.1-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 2.2.1-2ubuntu0.1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 2.2.1-2ubuntu0.2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 2.2.1-2ubuntu0.3 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:Pro:18.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:Pro:18.04) | = 2.5.1-1ubuntu1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:Pro:18.04) | = 2.6.0-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:Pro:18.04) | = 2.7.0-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:Pro:18.04) | = 2.8.0-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:Pro:18.04) | = 2.8.0-1ubuntu0.1~esm1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:Pro:20.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:Pro:20.04) | = 2.16.2-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:Pro:20.04) | = 2.16.3-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:Pro:20.04) | = 2.16.4-1ubuntu2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/mbedtls(Ubuntu:Pro:20.04) | = 2.16.4-1ubuntu2+esm1 | No fix listed |
References
- Debian Security Tracker CVE-2020-10932 vendor-advisory
- [debian-lts-announce] 20221225 [SECURITY] [DLA 3249-1] mbedtls security update mailing-list third-party-advisory
- FEDORA-2020-9a6e8e63e9 mailing-list third-party-advisory vendor-advisory
- FEDORA-2020-42564738a1 mailing-list third-party-advisory vendor-advisory
- tls.mbed.org issue-tracking release-notes
- tls.mbed.org issue-tracking vendor-advisory
- tls.mbed.org issue-tracking vendor-advisory
- security.alpinelinux.org vendor-advisory
- bugs.debian.org issue-tracking
- ubuntu.com issue-tracking
- www.cve.org issue-tracking