CVE-2024-31497 In PuTTY 0.68 through 0.80 before 0.81, biased ECDSA nonce generation allows an attacker to recover a user's NIST P-521 secret key via a quick attack in approximately 60 signatures. This is especially...
- Published
- Updated
- Exploit status
- No public exploit known
- CISA SSVC
- No known exploitation · automatable: no · technical impact: partial
- Technology
- UbuntuDebian
Description
In PuTTY 0.68 through 0.80 before 0.81, biased ECDSA nonce generation allows an attacker to recover a user's NIST P-521 secret key via a quick attack in approximately 60 signatures. This is especially important in a scenario where an adversary is able to read messages signed by PuTTY or Pageant. The required set of signed messages may be publicly readable because they are stored in a public Git service that supports use of SSH for commit signing, and the signatures were made by Pageant through an agent-forwarding mechanism. In other words, an adversary may already have enough signature information to compromise a victim's private key, even if there is no further use of vulnerable PuTTY versions. After a key compromise, an adversary may be able to conduct supply-chain attacks on software maintained in Git. A second, independent scenario is that the adversary is an operator of an SSH server to which the victim authenticates (for remote login or file copy), even though this server is not fully trusted by the victim, and the victim uses the same private key for SSH connections to other services operated by other entities. Here, the rogue server operator (who would otherwise have no way to determine the victim's private key) can derive the victim's private key, and then use it for unauthorized access to those other services. If the other services include Git services, then again it may be possible to conduct supply-chain attacks on software maintained in Git. This also affects, for example, FileZilla before 3.67.0, WinSCP before 6.3.3, TortoiseGit before 2.15.0.1, and TortoiseSVN through 1.14.6.
Upgrade path
30 packages: 19 fixed, 10 with no fix yet.
| Package | Affected | Fixed in | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| debian/filezilla(Debian 12) | = 3.63.0-1; = 3.63.0-1+deb12u1; = 3.63.0-1+deb12u2; = 3.63.0-1+deb12u3 +34 more | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu 16.04) | = 3.12.0.2-1ubuntu2; = 3.14.1-1ubuntu1; = 3.15.0.2-0ubuntu1; = 3.15.0.2-1ubuntu1 +1 more | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu 18.04) | = 3.27.0~rc1-1; = 3.28.0-1; All versions | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu 20.04) | = 3.39.0-2; = 3.45.1-3; = 3.45.1-3build1; = 3.46.3-1 +4 more | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu 22.04) | = 3.52.2-3; = 3.56.0-1; = 3.56.2-1; = 3.57.0-1 +4 more | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu 24.04) | = 3.65.0-3; = 3.66.1-2; = 3.66.1-3; = 3.66.1-3.2 +7 more | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu 16.04) | = 0.65-2; = 0.66-1; = 0.66-2; = 0.66-3 +6 more | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu 18.04) | = 0.70-1; = 0.70-2; = 0.70-3; = 0.70-4 +1 more | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu 20.04) | = 0.72-1; = 0.73-1; = 0.73-2; All versions | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu 22.04) | = 0.75-3; = 0.76-1; = 0.76-2; All versions | No fix listed | No fix yet |
| alpine/putty(Alpine v3.16) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/putty(Alpine v3.17) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/putty(Alpine v3.18) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/putty(Alpine v3.19) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/putty(Alpine v3.20) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/putty(Alpine v3.21) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/putty(Alpine v3.22) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/putty(Alpine v3.23) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 | Fixed |
| alpine/putty(Alpine v3.24) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 | Fixed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian 13) | < 3.67.0-1 | 3.67.0-1 | Fixed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian 14) | < 3.67.0-1 | 3.67.0-1 | Fixed |
| debian/putty(Debian 12) | < 0.78-2+deb12u2; = 0.78-2; = 0.78-2+deb12u1 | 0.78-2+deb12u2 | Fixed |
| debian/putty(Debian 13) | < 0.81-1 | 0.81-1 | Fixed |
| debian/putty(Debian 14) | < 0.81-1 | 0.81-1 | Fixed |
| filezilla-project FileZilla Client | < 3.67.0 | 3.67.0 | Fixed |
| putty | >= 0.68, < 0.81 | 0.81 | Fixed |
| tigris tortoisesvn | < 1.14.6 | 1.14.6 | Fixed |
| tortoisegit | < 2.15.0.1 | 2.15.0.1 | Fixed |
| winscp | < 6.3.3 | 6.3.3 | Fixed |
| fedoraproject fedora | = 38; = 39; = 40 | No fix listed | Versions listed |
Affected products
| Product | Affected versions | Fixed in |
|---|---|---|
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | All versions | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.63.0-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.63.0-1+deb12u1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.63.0-1+deb12u2 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.63.0-1+deb12u3 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.63.2.1-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.63.2.1-2 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.63.2.1-3 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.63.2.1-4 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.64.0-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.65.0-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.65.0-2 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.65.0-3 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.66.0-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.66.1-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.66.1-2 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.66.1-3 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.66.1-3.1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.66.1-3.2 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.66.1-4 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.66.4-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.66.4-2 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.66.5-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.66.5-2 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.67.0-1 | No fix listed |
Show 95 more
| Product | Affected versions | Fixed in |
|---|---|---|
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.67.1-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.67.1-2 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.67.1~rc1-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.68.0-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.68.0~rc1-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.68.1-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.69.3-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.69.5-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.69.6-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.69.6-2 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.70.6-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.70.6-2 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:12) | = 3.71.0-1 | No fix listed |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:13) | < 3.67.0-1 | 3.67.0-1 |
| debian/filezilla(Debian:14) | < 3.67.0-1 | 3.67.0-1 |
| debian/putty(Debian:12) | < 0.78-2+deb12u2 | 0.78-2+deb12u2 |
| debian/putty(Debian:12) | = 0.78-2 | No fix listed |
| debian/putty(Debian:12) | = 0.78-2+deb12u1 | No fix listed |
| debian/putty(Debian:13) | < 0.81-1 | 0.81-1 |
| debian/putty(Debian:14) | < 0.81-1 | 0.81-1 |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:22.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:22.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| putty | >= 0.68, < 0.81 | 0.81 |
| alpine/putty(Alpine:v3.16) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 |
| alpine/putty(Alpine:v3.17) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 |
| alpine/putty(Alpine:v3.18) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 |
| alpine/putty(Alpine:v3.19) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 |
| alpine/putty(Alpine:v3.20) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 |
| alpine/putty(Alpine:v3.21) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 |
| alpine/putty(Alpine:v3.22) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 |
| alpine/putty(Alpine:v3.23) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 |
| alpine/putty(Alpine:v3.24) | >= 0.68, < 0.81-r0 | 0.81-r0 |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:24.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| filezilla-project FileZilla Client | < 3.67.0 | 3.67.0 |
| winscp | < 6.3.3 | 6.3.3 |
| tortoisegit | < 2.15.0.1 | 2.15.0.1 |
| tigris tortoisesvn | < 1.14.6 | 1.14.6 |
| fedoraproject fedora | = 38 | No fix listed |
| fedoraproject fedora | = 39 | No fix listed |
| fedoraproject fedora | = 40 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:16.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 3.12.0.2-1ubuntu2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 3.14.1-1ubuntu1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 3.15.0.2-0ubuntu1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 3.15.0.2-1ubuntu1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:16.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 0.65-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 0.66-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 0.66-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 0.66-3 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 0.66-4 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 0.67-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 0.67-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 0.67-3build0.16.04.1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:16.04) | = 0.67-3+deb9u1build0.16.04.1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:18.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:18.04) | = 3.27.0~rc1-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:18.04) | = 3.28.0-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:18.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:18.04) | = 0.70-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:18.04) | = 0.70-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:18.04) | = 0.70-3 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:18.04) | = 0.70-4 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:20.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:20.04) | = 3.39.0-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:20.04) | = 3.45.1-3 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:20.04) | = 3.45.1-3build1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:20.04) | = 3.46.3-1~build1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:20.04) | = 3.46.3-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:20.04) | = 3.46.3-1build1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:20.04) | = 3.46.3-1ubuntu0.1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:20.04) | All versions | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:20.04) | = 0.72-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:20.04) | = 0.73-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:20.04) | = 0.73-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:22.04) | = 3.52.2-3 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:22.04) | = 3.56.0-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:22.04) | = 3.56.2-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:22.04) | = 3.57.0-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:22.04) | = 3.57.0-1build1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:22.04) | = 3.58.0-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:22.04) | = 3.58.0-1ubuntu0.1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:22.04) | = 0.75-3 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:22.04) | = 0.76-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/putty(Ubuntu:22.04) | = 0.76-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:24.04) | = 3.65.0-3 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:24.04) | = 3.66.1-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:24.04) | = 3.66.1-3 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:24.04) | = 3.66.1-3.2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:24.04) | = 3.66.1-4 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:24.04) | = 3.66.4-1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:24.04) | = 3.66.4-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:24.04) | = 3.66.5-2 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:24.04) | = 3.66.5-2build1 | No fix listed |
| ubuntu/filezilla(Ubuntu:24.04) | = 3.66.5-2build2 | No fix listed |
References
- Debian Security Tracker CVE-2024-31497 issue-tracking third-party-advisory vendor-advisory
- Ubuntu CVE tracker issue-tracking vendor-advisory
- www.cve.org issue-tracking
- www.chiark.greenend.org.uk issue-tracking release-notes vendor-advisory
- filezilla-project.org issue-tracking release-notes
- www.chiark.greenend.org.uk issue-tracking vendor-advisory
- www.openwall.com issue-tracking mailing-list third-party-advisory
- tartarus.org issue-tracking product
- docs.ccv.brown.edu issue-tracking product
- news.ycombinator.com issue-tracking
- winscp.net issue-tracking third-party-advisory
- tortoisegit.org issue-tracking third-party-advisory
- github.com issue-tracking third-party-advisory
- bugzilla.redhat.com issue-tracking
- bugzilla.suse.com issue-tracking
- twitter.com issue-tracking press-media-coverage
- git.tartarus.org issue-tracking mailing-list patch
- www.reddit.com issue-tracking press-media-coverage
- github.com issue-tracking third-party-advisory
- www.bleepingcomputer.com issue-tracking press-media-coverage
- twitter.com issue-tracking press-media-coverage
- securityonline.info issue-tracking press-media-coverage
- FEDORA-2024-8401d42de6 issue-tracking mailing-list third-party-advisory vendor-advisory
- FEDORA-2024-ff9a2fb31c mailing-list third-party-advisory vendor-advisory
- FEDORA-2024-0489e7ba1e mailing-list third-party-advisory vendor-advisory
- FEDORA-2024-08a4a5ead8 mailing-list third-party-advisory vendor-advisory
- FEDORA-2024-cba85cc558 mailing-list third-party-advisory vendor-advisory
- [oss-security] 20240415 CVE-2024-31497: Secret Key Recovery of NIST P-521 Private Keys Through Biased ECDSA Nonces in PuTTY Client mailing-list third-party-advisory
- [debian-lts-announce] 20240620 [SECURITY] [DLA 3839-1] putty security update mailing-list
- www.vicarius.io
- lists.fedoraproject.org
- lists.fedoraproject.org
- lists.fedoraproject.org
- lists.fedoraproject.org
- security.alpinelinux.org vendor-advisory